http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OetAV-4D6Uc

| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
AndyLeeAKP |
test fight with friend |
Lead | |
|
my good friend Neil Dang wants to start getting in on these martial arts films. he seems to like being on screen. He is really into MMA and so the first test
we did with him started with a clean fight and releases to a full out MMA brawl. didnt seem to succeed much of like a flash point style, which was what i was
aiming for but it was worth the shot. first time doing an MMA style fight i guess. Neil seems to be a pretty good screen fighter MMA wise. well Criticize all
you want. we need it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OetAV-4D6Uc |
|||
saberdjedi |
|||
|
I liked what you were trying to do, it was mma without being too Flashpoint-ish, and the length and structure actually made it somewhat realistic. Just make
sure those hits line up. Extra points for being like #2 to use the arm triangle in a fight scene. SPL does it briefly as well.
Derek
The Breakfast Machine |
|||
darrenh7 |
|||
|
It was a bit realistic except that the attacks still looked held back. I give you props on the idea... just need a little work on the execution. Lots of the
shots worked well.
DARDREX PRODUCTIONS.
No life! A camera! And High kicks! Kung Fu San So, Shotokan Karate, Muay Thai, Taekwondo, and Jeet Kune Do. http://www.youtube.com/user/dardrex777 |
|||
Graeme Noble |
|||
|
I didn't like it.
Some of it was executed well but it was too slow and more of a wrestle than a martial arts/kickboxing style. I'm a Hong Kong style man, and prefer to see fights of that nature. But it was decent for what it was, just not my style - i'd like to see more of a fight next time.
Graeme Noble
Kung Fu Hall of Fame |
|||
darrenh7 |
|||
Graeme Noble wrote: Graeme you shouldn't be degrading their video just because it's not your style... same with anyone's video. These guys set out to do more realistic brawl style not 80s kickboxing.... it's not all that is out their and it's good to trying new things before your choreography starts looking the same and repetitive every fight. It's only fair to judge the film based as it is....
DARDREX PRODUCTIONS.
No life! A camera! And High kicks! Kung Fu San So, Shotokan Karate, Muay Thai, Taekwondo, and Jeet Kune Do. http://www.youtube.com/user/dardrex777 |
|||
saberdjedi |
|||
|
Graeme, wrestling is a martial art, and all of the moves done in that video exist outside of wrestling as well. Everything that seemed to be
"wrestling" in this fight were all pretty formal MMA techniques.
Derek
The Breakfast Machine |
|||
Graeme Noble |
|||
|
I'm judging the fight the way I see it. I'm being honest.
I'm not going to say something else just to be technically right.
Graeme Noble
Kung Fu Hall of Fame |
|||
DevinWho |
|||
|
Well then the criticism isn't very valid than Graeme if your judging off of two different styles. We understand you prefer a nice combination base
choreography but when leaving comments on things like this, you have to analyze quality. Not personal preference. Thats like walking into a opera and
complaining that the fat chick isn't beating on the fat man
|
|||
Graeme Noble |
|||
|
Well I judge these fights from an on-screen Kung perspective...
I said in my previous post some positive comments. I was trying not to be unreasonable.
Graeme Noble
Kung Fu Hall of Fame |
|||
pascalaka |
|||
DevinWho wrote: hahahaha, that comparison was funny right there. |
|||
Rising Tiger |
|||
Graeme Noble wrote: I honestly didn't see anything constructive about your comment ("executed well but it was too slow" was probably the closest thing to constructive criticism) And I think you're missing the point of this fight if you're judging it strictly from an "on-screen Kung perspective"...
|
|||
darrenh7 |
|||
|
Graeme not all of us do HK Kickboxing style.... Micah does Thai, Jay does wrestling mix with HK and Korean, I myself combine everything I see, these guys are
more for a brawl style (at least in this vid),
These comparisons are pretty unfair when people have their own style. Judge on the performance... And yeah... comments like this aren't really constructive.
DARDREX PRODUCTIONS.
No life! A camera! And High kicks! Kung Fu San So, Shotokan Karate, Muay Thai, Taekwondo, and Jeet Kune Do. http://www.youtube.com/user/dardrex777 |
|||
DevinWho |
|||
|
Okay No more need for grouping up. Lets get back on topic of the video. I'd really like to stop this before anything gets started
|
|||
AndyLeeAKP |
|||
|
yea.... i agree with devin
lets get back to the criticizm. i need it haha |
|||
darrenh7 |
|||
|
The set up and choreography as I said is good... just punch like you mean it and hold hold back and then you got it dude... that and maybe edit just a little
tighter....
DARDREX PRODUCTIONS.
No life! A camera! And High kicks! Kung Fu San So, Shotokan Karate, Muay Thai, Taekwondo, and Jeet Kune Do. http://www.youtube.com/user/dardrex777 |
|||
Graeme Noble |
|||
|
AndyLee - sorry if you think my comments are ridiculous or unfair. I do apologise.
I'll be honest and say that it isn't my style, so perhaps I shouldn't have said anything at all - but I think you could have potential to throw in some HK kickboxing because in my opinion that looks the best. Try and work on your speed, the editing and executions looked fine but it was a bit slow.
Graeme Noble
Kung Fu Hall of Fame |
|||
naikanomtom |
|||
|
Andy, you and Neil did nicely in this test fight. Good camera work, and nice use of MMA. I agree with Darren that you could hit with a little more oomph, but
its good,...helluva lot better than what I can do. MAKE MOAR!!
|
|||
AndyLeeAKP |
|||
|
the good part about this video seems to be the MMA. im not a MMA guy myself so i asked neil and his little brother, phyman (http://youtube.com/watch?v=LahyH-VXXAY) to help me choreograph the MMA. credits to little phyman for helping me
out with the triangle lock!
|
|||
DevinWho |
|||
|
Stop hoggin all the fights Andy you dickcheese!
|
|||